Florida Professors Banned From Testifying Against Florda Anti-Voting Law

The decision by the University of Florida (UF) to muzzle three professors from testifying against a new state law restricting people from their constitutional right to vote has exploded into a political and public relations battle. 

In a case challenging Senate Bill 90, UF political science professors Daniel Smith, Michael McDonald, and Sharon Austin were notified via email that their request to serve as experts was denied. Now, according to reporting by The New York Times, five more professors have come forward about being banned from testifying.

The body that sets the accreditation for the university opened an inquiry to determine whether banning the faculty was in legal conflict with the “academic freedom” and “undue political influence” standards of the school, Miami Herald reported.  In reaction to the accreditation threat, the university’s president ordered a review of the decision to ban the professors from testifying.

“The University of Florida stands firmly behind its commitment to uphold our most sacred right as Americans, the right to free speech, and to faculty members’ right to academic freedom,” UF said in a statement. “Nothing is more fundamental to our existence as an institution.”

Since the start of all of this controversy, all roads have conspicuously led to Gov. Ron DeSantis, who of course denies any involvement.   "This is an internal U.F. issue and not the sort of thing that the executive branch would be involved in,” Christina Pushaw, DeSantis’ spokeswoman told the Times. “Governor DeSantis has always championed free speech, open inquiry and viewpoint diversity on college and university campuses.” 

It seems awfully suspicious that the one professor in Florida allowed to testify is one who chose to defend the state's oppressive and racist voting law, doesn't it?  Florida International University professor Dairo Moreno was allowed to testify as an expert witness in defense of every GOP-drawn redistricting map since 1994, according to the Tampa Bay Times. 

So despite the numerous lies and obfuscations from DeSantis and his administration, the reality is when professors speak out against Florida’s GOP policies they professors are banned, and when they speak in support of the policies, they have the opportunity to testify. 

“It’s creating an environment which is putting intolerable pressure on universities to comply with the political policies of this administration, for sure,” Dr. Jeffrey L. Goldhagen, a longtime professor and administrator at the university’s College of Medicine in Jacksonville, told the Times. “I don’t think there’s any question about that.”

In a letter of support of the three professors, over 80 professors accused the university of “a serious violation of academic freedom and faculty speech rights,” adding: “We call on University of Florida administrators to reverse their decision, and to allow Professors Sharon Austin, Michael McDonald, and Daniel Smith to offer expert testimony in this case.”

This is just the latest in DeSantis’ fascistic style of governance, as his June legislation attempted to do against the “indoctrination” of students. The law, which went into effect July 1, requires universities and colleges to “survey” students, faculty, and staff about their beliefs with regard to “intellectual diversity.”  The survey will ascertain “the extent to which competing ideas and perspectives are presented” in public schools and to learn if teachers and students “feel free to express beliefs and viewpoints on campus and in the classroom,” according to the bill.  DeSantis suggested the information gathered could be used to cut funding if the schools were found to be ”indoctrinating” students. 

In a letter to UF, attorneys Paul Donnelly and Conor Flynn wrote, “The university cannot silence the professors on matters of great public importance. These professors are citizens entitled to participate in the marketplace of ideas.”   Professor McDonald tweeted a video of Tom Petty’s “I Won’t Back Down.” He and his colleagues “are the faculty being denied our constitutional right to free speech by the university,” he wrote.